Times and PlacesVoicesJust for KidsEducationMuseums


Elementary
  Alaska
  Salem
High School

LESSON PLANS

MIDDLE SCHOOL:
Cultural Exchange (Alaska)

Teacher Summary
Students spend two days considering what happens when people of different cultures first meet. They read oral traditions from Alaska Natives that describe their first encounters with Europeans or Americans. They explore their own reactions to cultural differences.

Content Standards:
  1. Students will learn the name and geographic location of the Tlingit Indians of Southeast Alaska
  2. Students will read several versions of a cultural encounter between Europeans and Tlingits
  3. Students will discuss the role of cultural perspective in history and compare cultural perspectives
  4. Students will discuss alternative endings to the stories they read


Preparations/Supplies Needed:
Log into the New Trade Winds site ahead of time and print copies of the Native Peoples and Languages map, the Southeast Culture Worksheet, and the Culture Contact Worksheet. Note that each student will need two copies of the Culture Contact Worksheet. Refer to the NTW glossary for help in pronouncing the names of the groups.



Curriculm Index
Teacher Summary
Content Standards
Preparations/Supplies Needed

DAY 1 LESSON PLANS
DAY 2 LESSON PLANS

Student Summary

Suggested Reading
"First Russians"

LaPérouse's Account of First Meeting with the Tlingits in Lituya Bay

 


DAY 1 LESSON PLANS
Implementation of Language Arts/Art/Social Studies:

I: Pre-Assessment/Introduction: Discussion may be generated by inquiry. This will enable the teacher to discover what prior knowledge the student has

  1. Introduce Alaska and its Native peoples to students. Review the five Alaska Native groups and pronounce their names. Now direct their attention to southeast Alaska, homeland of the Tlingits, Haidas, Tsimshians, and Eyaks. Explain that this lesson is about the Tlingits and the first time they encountered European visitors to their shores.
  2. Talk about culture contact. Have students ever visited a place where they spoke, acted, ate, or looked different from the local people? Ask them to describe the experiences. Ask students how they would feel if they discovered that they are dressed differently from everyone else. If they report discomfort, ask why they feel that way. What is it about looking like someone that is comforting?
  3. Conduct an experiment. Divide the students into two groups. Give those in one group a piece of paper that says, "One of you will ask the other group the following questions:

    a. Did you bring your lunch today?
    b. Are you going away for spring [or summer] vacation?
    c. Do you have any brothers or sisters?"

    Give the other group a piece of paper that says, "If the answer to a question is "yes," stand up and turn around, then sit down. If the answer is "no," make an "OK" sign with your hand."

  4. Instruct a student from the first group to ask the questions, and those from the second group to answer them, all at once, in the manner directed. After all three questions have been asked, discuss with students:

    a. Did the first group understand what the answers meant?
    b. How did the first group feel when the second group gave its answers?
    c. How did the second group feel when its answers were not understood?
    d. How might this relate to a situation of first contact between Alaska Natives and Europeans?

  5. Provide background on the Tlingits by directing students to the general information on Alaska on the website. Then direct them to the map of Alaska. If they click on the southeast section, they will learn something about the trade the Tlingits engaged in during the days before the coming of Europeans. This will give them background on Tlingit culture. Distribute the Southeast Cultural Worksheet-PDF and have students fill it in.

DAY 2 LESSON PLANS

I:Set the scene for the story of the first meeting between Tlingits and Europeans. Tell students to imagine that they are Tlingit Indians of the L'uk.nax.ádi clan living in Lituya Bay. Locate the area on a map of Alaska. The story would be told in the wintertime, inside a large wood-plank clan house. The listeners would be warmly wrapped in bear or deer skins as they listened to the elder recount the story. It's a story they have heard many times before, but they love to hear it again. They think that parts of it are very funny.

II:Provide students with two copies of the Culture Contact Worksheet - PDF and instruct them to fill in one sheet for Tlingits, one for LePérouse as they read the selections. Instruct the students on navigating the New Trade Winds site to reach the Cultural Meetings/Alaska - PDF section. Students will find the following six selections, which should be read in this order:

  1. Cultural Exchanges
  2. "First Russians" told by Charlie White
  3. "Raven Boat" told by Jennie White
  4. "The Coming of the First White Man" told by George R. Betts
  5. Native Account of the Meeting between LaPérouse and the Tlingit" from written sources. Click here for story.
  6. LaPérouse's Account of First Meeting with the Tlingits in Lituya Bay. Click here for journal.

III:In class, discuss the readings and students' completed worksheets. What were the perspectives of the different witnesses? Why were they different? How would students have changed history if they could?